Chinese American gangster transformed cartel money laundering
In 2017, US Drug Enforcement Administration agents following
the money from cocaine deals in Memphis, Tennessee, identified a mysterious
figure in Mexico entrusted by drug lords with their millions: a Chinese
American gangster named Xizhi Li.
As the agents tracked Li’s activity across the Americas and
Asia, they realized he wasn’t just another money launderer. He was a pioneer.
Operating with the acumen of a financier and the tradecraft of a spy, he had
helped devise an innovative system that revolutionized the drug underworld and
fortified the cartels.
Li hit on a better way to address a problem that has long
bedeviled the world’s drug lords: how to turn the mountains of grimy twenties
and hundreds amassed on US streets into legitimate fortunes they can spend on
yachts, mansions, weapons, technology – and bribes to police and politicians.
For years, the Mexican cartels that supply the US market
with cocaine, heroin and fentanyl smuggled truckloads of bulk cash to Mexico,
where they used banks and exchange houses to move the money into the financial
system. And they also hired middlemen — often Colombian or Lebanese specialists
who charged as much as 18 cents on the dollar — to launder their billions.
Those methods were costly, took weeks or even months to
complete and exposed the stockpiled cash to risks — damage, robbery,
confiscation.
Enter Li. About six years ago, federal anti-drug agents in
Chicago saw early signs of what would become a tectonic change. They trailed
cartel operatives transporting drug cash to a new destination: Chinatown, an
immigrant enclave in the flatlands about two miles south of the city’s rampart
of lakefront skyscrapers.
Agents on stakeout watched as cartel operatives delivered
suitcases full of cash to Chinese couriers directed by Li. Furtive exchanges
took place in motels and parking lots. The couriers didn’t have criminal
records or carry guns; they were students, waiters, drivers. Neither side spoke
much English, so they used a prearranged signal: a photo of a serial number on
a dollar bill.
After the handoff, the couriers alerted their Chinese bosses
in Mexico, who quickly sent pesos to the bank accounts or safe houses of
Mexican drug lords. Li then executed a chain of transactions through China, the
United States and Latin America to launder the dollars.
His powerful international connections made his service
cheap, fast and efficient; he even guaranteed free replacement of cartel cash
lost in transit. Li and his fellow Chinese money launderers married market
forces: drug lords wanting to get rid of dollars and a Chinese elite desperate
to acquire dollars. The new model blew away the competition.
“At no time in the history of organized crime is there an
example where a revenue stream has been taken over like this, and without a
shot being fired,” said retired DEA agent Thomas Cindric, a veteran of the
elite Special Operations Division. “This has enriched the Mexican cartels
beyond their wildest dreams.”
As they investigated Li’s tangled financial dealings, US
agents came across evidence indicating that his money laundering schemes
involved Chinese government officials and the Communist Party elite. China’s
omnipresent security forces tightly control and monitor its state-run economy.
Yet Li and others moved tens of millions of dollars among
Chinese banks and companies with seeming impunity, according to court documents
and national security officials. The criminal rings exploited a landscape in
which more than $3.8 trillion of capital has left China since 2006, making the
country the world’s top “exporter of hot money,” said John
Cassara, a former US Treasury Department investigator, in testimony to a
Canadian commission of inquiry.
Admiral Craig Faller, a senior US military leader, told
Congress last year that Chinese launderers had emerged as the “No
1 underwriter" of drug trafficking in the Western Hemisphere. The
Chinese government is “at least tacitly supporting” the laundering activity,
testified Faller, who led the US Southern Command, which oversees military
activity in Latin America.
In an interview with ProPublica, the now-retired Faller
elaborated on his little-noticed testimony. He said China has “the world’s
largest and most sophisticated state security apparatus. So there’s no doubt
that they have the ability to stop things if they want to. They don’t have any
desire to stop this. There’s a lot of theories as to why they don’t. But it is
certainly aided and abetted by the attitude and way that the People’s Republic
of China views the globe.”
Some US officials go farther, arguing that Chinese
authorities have decided as a matter of policy to foster the drug trade in the
Americas in order to destabilize the region and spread corruption, addiction
and death here.
“We suspected a Chinese ideological and strategic motivation
behind the drug and money activity,” said former senior FBI official Frank
Montoya Jr, who served as a top counterintelligence official at the Office of
the Director of National Intelligence. “To fan the flames of hate and division.
The Chinese have seen the advantages of the drug trade. If fentanyl helps them
and hurts this country, why not?”
More than half a dozen national security veterans
interviewed by ProPublica expressed similar views, most of them speaking on the
condition of anonymity because of the sensitive subject. But they acknowledged
that the alleged state complicity is difficult to prove.
Beijing rejects
such accusations. And the question of whether China actively supports
money laundering and the flow of fentanyl and other drugs to the US remains a
matter of debate in the US national security community.
“There is so much corruption today in mainland China it
becomes hard to distinguish a policy or campaign from generalized criminality,”
said an Asian American former intelligence official with long experience
watching Chinese crime and espionage.
The Chinese embassy in Washington did not respond to a
detailed request for comment for this story.
The takeover of drug-related money laundering by Chinese
organized crime has drawn global attention. In Australia, authorities
are investigating a Chinese syndicate that allegedly moved hundreds of
millions of dollars around the world for clients, including a cousin of Chinese
President Xi Jinping, according to news reports. (Xi’s cousin has not been
charged with a crime, and the Chinese foreign ministry has dismissed reports
about inquiries into his activities as “gossip.”)
Europol has warned that Chinese money laundering groups
“present a growing threat to Europe.”
The US State Department estimates that $154 billion in
illicit funds a year passes through China, calling it “of great concern.”
“We used to have a regular dialogue with the Chinese
specifically on things like money laundering, counternarcotics policies,”
Assistant Secretary Todd Robinson, who leads the Bureau of International
Narcotics and Law Enforcement Affairs, said in an interview. “And since that
has stopped, it has not been clear, we’ve not really been able to get a handle
on how much of this is criminal organizations and how much of it is criminal
organizations connected to or suborning Chinese government officials.”
Xi has led a well-publicized crusade against
corruption but
it has been mainly a purge of rivals, according to US national security
officials and Chinese dissidents. In fact, they said, Chinese intelligence
services have quietly expanded their ties with Chinese mafias, known as triads,
for mutual benefit.
“There is no question there is interconnectivity between
Chinese organized crime and the Chinese state,” said Montoya. “The party
operates in organized-crime-type fashion. There are parallels to Russia, where
organized crime has been co-opted by the Russian government and Putin’s
security services.”
The Li case led federal agents in an unexpected direction:
an investigation of a possible Chinese covert operation to penetrate American
politics. The DEA agents stumbled across Li’s enigmatic associate, an
expatriate Chinese businessman named Tao Liu. After moving from Mexico to New
York, he launched a high-rolling quest for political influence that included at
least two meetings with then-President Donald Trump.
Both the DEA and FBI pursued Liu, suspecting he had ties to
Chinese spy agencies. They wanted to know how and why a wanted Chinese criminal
had gained access to the president of the United States.
Although authorities convicted Li and Liu of money
laundering and other crimes, the political and diplomatic aspects of the
groundbreaking investigations of them are still largely secret.
Citing still-open investigations, the DEA declined to
discuss the case or even the general issue of how Chinese organized crime launders
profits for the cartels. The Justice Department and FBI declined requests for
comment. Lawyers who represented Li rejected requests for interviews with them
or their client.
To explore the full dimensions of the case, ProPublica
interviewed more than two dozen current and former national security officials,
as well as lawyers and others involved. ProPublica granted some of them
anonymity, either because they were not authorized to talk publicly or because
of concerns about their security.
ProPublica also reviewed court files, social media,
governmental reports and other material. Many details — about the suspected
role of Chinese officials, the hunt across the globe, the links to US politics
— are being reported for the first time.
The Aura of Juan Lee
In 2008, Rigo Polanco met a cocaine trafficker who called
himself Juan Lee. It was one of 17 aliases that Xizhi Li accumulated in a
criminal career that was just getting started.
Polanco, a California anti-drug agent, had spent weeks
undercover stalking Li, who was looking for a high-volume supplier. But the guy
was a ghost. He used multiple phones. He hid behind intermediaries. Finally, he
agreed to meet Polanco at a Denny’s by the Pomona Freeway in the suburban
sprawl of the San Gabriel Valley.
On June 24, Polanco’s Los Angeles County task force deployed
surveillance around the diner. Polanco introduced himself as Alfredo, a corrupt
Customs and Border Protection officer with access to cocaine. He sat down with
Li, Li’s 25-year-old Mexican American wife and her brother.
At 35, Li stood 5-foot-7 and weighed about 135 pounds. But
he was imposing. He spoke fluent, Mexican-accented Spanish, wore a Rolex and
emanated menace.
“The aura of Juan Lee among the people around him was,
‘Don’t cross this guy,’” Polanco recalled in an interview. “There was some
sense of fear of him among his associates.”
Li grew up in a unique subculture where crime spoke many
languages and crossed borders with ease. The experience served him well.
He was born in a rural area of Guangdong province in 1973.
About 10 years later, the family migrated to Mexicali, a Mexican city on the
California border that is home to a large Chinese community. Chinese
restaurants fill La Chinesca, the Chinatown. In the early 20th century, an
underground tunnel complex was a refuge from the desert heat — and a site for
gambling and cross-border crime schemes.
Li attended school and worked long shifts in a family
restaurant. But one of his close relatives smuggled migrants and contraband
into the United States, former investigators say. When Li was about 16, his
family migrated to Southern California. He slid into crime in the 1990s and
with help from relatives became an associate of the 14K triad, a Chinese
criminal organization, according to law enforcement documents and former
investigators.
Li obtained US citizenship and had four children with a
Chinese-born woman. In 2005, he opened the Lucky City Restaurant in the suburb
of Monterey Park in Los Angeles County. The restaurant quickly became a den of
drug trafficking and human smuggling, according to an affidavit written by a
DEA investigator and sources familiar with the case.
By then, Li’s triad and family connections had helped him
cultivate relationships with Chinese officials with diplomatic status in the
United States, according to former investigators. He also recruited a corrupt
US border inspector to help with smuggling, according to law enforcement
documents and former investigators.
Li’s hectic life bridged the Latino and Asian communities.
He had two children with his Mexican American wife, whose family had useful
cartel connections, according to interviews and court documents.
At the same time, Li maintained ties to his birthplace.
Around 2007, he took Chinese relatives to Guangdong for the Qingming Festival,
when families clean the tombs of their ancestors. Basking in the role of
benevolent immigrant, he “funded the renovation of our village, transforming
the muddy land into streets,” his sister wrote to a federal judge years later.
Back in the smoggy San Gabriel Valley, his prolific criminal
activity drew investigations by the DEA and FBI. But Polanco’s team of Los
Angeles County officers didn’t know about those open cases when they went after
him in 2008.
During a second meeting at a seafood restaurant, Li told
Polanco that he was smuggling 30-kilogram loads of cocaine through Mexico to
Hong Kong, making $60,000 a kilogram. He also sent cocaine to Canada. And he
had a sideline smuggling Chinese migrants through Cuba.
This is no run-of-the-mill thug, Polanco thought. Mexico was
violent. Cuba was a police state. Canada and Hong Kong were hotbeds of Chinese
organized crime. You needed well-placed allies to navigate among those cultures
and countries.
“It all added up to this picture of a very shrewd and
cautious and sophisticated operator,” Polanco said. “There was a lot of
sophistication in what he was doing, even then.”
After negotiations with the undercover agent, Li agreed to
buy an initial 20 kilograms of cocaine. On July 14, he sent a young Asian man
in a Mercedes to a supermarket parking lot to deliver $200,000. Polanco’s team
captured the bagman and other accomplices. The bagman and Li’s brother-in-law
pleaded guilty to drug trafficking offenses, while charges against the wife were
dropped.
But Li fled south across the border. He soon proved
Polanco’s instincts correct.
In Mexico City, Li rebounded fast.
Qiyun Chen was from his hometown and worked in her family’s
retail business. Only in her early 20s, she became his romantic and criminal
partner, according to court documents and former investigators. Her charm and
intelligence impressed gangsters and cops alike. (Chen could not be reached for
comment.)
Chen introduced Li to her own network in the Chinese Mexican
community, including a formidable trafficker known as the Iron Lady. In her
online communications, Chen called herself Chinaloa. The alias fused the words
China and Sinaloa, the state that has spawned many drug lords.
It baptized her as a player in a multilingual subculture
that she and Li created. Their text messages combined Chinese and Spanish. Li
used the online handles JL 007 and Organización Diplomática (Diplomatic
Organization).
The couple divided their time among luxurious homes in
Mexico City, Cancun and Guatemala, making good money smuggling drugs and
migrants. But they saw a new opportunity in money laundering.
In 2011, Li went to Guatemala City to buy a casino. Located
in a Holiday Inn, it had a ’90s-era decor that didn’t exactly conjure images of
James Bond in Monte Carlo.
Nonetheless, Li struck an all-inclusive deal with the owner.
He bought his casino, his casino license — and his identity. The US fugitive
became a Guatemalan gambling entrepreneur, according to court documents.
Along the way, Li had developed a complementary racket:
selling fraudulent documents. Li himself had five passports from three
countries. The fake papers were professionally done. Li infiltrated corrupt
Latin American bureaucracies that sell real passports, identity cards, even
birth certificates. He also had a government-connected source for passports in
Hong Kong. Li charged about $15,000 per document, according to interviews and
court files.
The same year Li bought the casino, a cafe owner in Mexico
City introduced him to a wealthy Chinese expatriate who wanted a Guatemalan
passport. The new arrival was a portly, baggy-faced 35-year-old named Tao Liu.
It proved a providential encounter.
Li took his client in a private helicopter to the
southernmost Mexican state of Chiapas. They landed in the jungle and trudged
across the border into Guatemala.
“Bodyguards with weapons and vehicles were waiting on the
other side,” said Liu’s lawyer, Jonathan Simms. “They take them to Li’s mansion
in Guatemala. Li leaves him there and goes to get the passports. Tao spent time
in that mansion waiting with other Chinese clients for Li to bring back the
documents. He got to know the other people there pretty well.”
While at the safe house, Liu met a senior Chinese military
officer who also bought a fraudulent document from Li, Simms said. Years later,
Liu identified the officer in a photo shown to him by US agents.
Investigators say that episode contributed to evidence that
Li provided fake papers, and other criminal services, to Chinese officials in
Latin America, where China is an economic and diplomatic power. Foreign
passports and multiple identities enable Chinese operatives overseas to engage
in covert activity, launder money or take refuge from their government if
accused of corruption.
The national security threat posed by Li’s passport racket
later caused the DEA to bring in the State Department’s Diplomatic Security
Service to conduct its own investigation, which continues today.
After the Guatemala expedition, Liu and Li became friends.
They gambled at the casino and took women to the Bahamas. Although Liu had
access to money and power, he was also an admitted brazen lawbreaker. Sometimes
his dubious immigration status forced him to enter Mexico by car or bus, and he
bragged about bluffing or bribing border officers, according to court
documents, his lawyer and law enforcement officials.
The two men did not seem like kindred spirits. Li was thin;
Liu was obese. Li was reserved; Liu was gregarious. It is hard to find photos
of Li; Liu bombarded social media with scenes of his extravagant lifestyle.
But they were both globetrotting outlaws. And Liu played a
crucial early role in building Li’s empire, according to current and former law
enforcement officials and other sources. A US indictment later alleged: “TAO
[Liu] worked with LI to begin money laundering in locations including Mexico
and Guatemala.”
In later conversations recorded by the DEA, Liu described
himself as an influential mentor who taught Li how to launder money, according
to court documents and interviews. Liu’s lawyer argued that his client’s
admissions were exaggerations. But the investigators tended to believe Liu’s
account.
“The DEA thought that they were partners in the money
laundering,” a former national security official said. “And they were
definitely working closely together.”
Investigators believe Liu used his connections in China and
the diaspora to recruit rich people who needed US dollars. A sign of Liu’s
access to that underworld: he had another associate in Hong Kong, known as “the
queen of underground banking,” who provided black market money services to the
Chinese elite, according to Chinese court documents and press reports.
Stocked with cash and guns, Li’s Guatemalan casino became a
base of his emerging venture. He started bringing Chinese nationals to the
casino: some of them politically connected, others corrupt officials, others
expatriates, according to interviews and court documents. They mingled with
Latin American drug traffickers, the second essential element in his scheme.
The casino was a showcase to demonstrate to both sides that Li could deliver,
court documents say.
The wealthy Chinese “had a need,” Simms said. “The cartels
had a need. Li put it together.”
Mirror Transactions
Many ethnic diasporas have developed informal systems for
moving money and funneling cash — earned honestly or illegally — into the
legitimate international economy.
For decades, underground banking systems served the elite of
the Chinese Communist Party, or CCP, especially after the totalitarian regime
opened its command economy to global capitalism. Starting around 2013, Xi’s
anti-corruption crusade pushed the elite to spirit more money overseas. A
yearly limit of $50,000 on capital flight increased a demand for US dollars.
“The underground banking system in China was pretty much
self-sufficient just dealing with Chinese criminal organizations and the
Chinese diaspora,” said John Tobon, the Homeland Security Investigations
special agent in charge in Honolulu, who
has written on the topic. “And it was then when all of these restrictions
came in, when the CCP members could no longer count on doing it the easy way
... that the supply of dollars became an issue.”
Li and other enterprising criminals identified a seemingly
limitless source of dollars: the Latin American drug trade. To amass the cash,
Li offered the cartels unheard-of money laundering deals.
“With the Colombians, it had been an 18% to 13% commission,”
said Cindric, the retired DEA agent. “The Chinese are doing it for 1 to 2% on
average. And the speed at which they do it is unbelievable. The Chinese
absorbed the risk. You know it will get paid.”
Li deployed dozens of couriers from Los Angeles to Atlanta.
Just two couriers in Chicago picked up more than $10 million from cartel
operatives in a seven-month period between 2016 and 2017, according to law
enforcement documents.
“We saw the Chinese enter the market,” said Daniel Morro, a
former senior HSI official in Chicago. “It was super-intriguing. We had never
seen it before.”
If the couriers delivered, they collected a 1% fee. If not,
they were on the hook with Li.
On March 11, 2016, Nebraska state troopers stopped a rental
car on a desolate highway. They confiscated $340,000 and released the two
couriers, who were driving from Chicago to Los Angeles. A courier phoned Li,
who called a cartel representative in Mexico and sent a bank transfer to
replace the lost load. The courier and his relatives rapidly reimbursed Li by
depositing money in US bank accounts, court documents say.
“He was a hard-ass,” said Michael Ciesliga, a former DEA
investigator. “No nonsense. All business. Very strict, very hard even on his
family.”
Li’s system generally worked like this: Cartel operatives in
the United States would arrange a “contract” with him, often to launder about
$350,000, a quantity of cash that fit into a suitcase.
Cartel transporters handed over the dollar loads to Li’s
couriers, who sent Li or his lieutenants a photo confirming the handoff. Li
then delivered the sums in Mexican pesos to drug lords from safe houses in
Mexico stocked with that currency. The first stage, providing swift service to
the cartels, was complete.
Li’s profits came from other players in the scheme: rich
Chinese willing to lose money in order to obtain dollars outside China and
Latin American import/export firms needing Chinese currency to do business in
China.
Li’s couriers often drove loads of cash to New York or Los
Angeles, which have large Chinese immigrant populations. Li “sold” the currency
to wealthy Chinese clients or their expatriate relatives or representatives. As
part of the deal, Li himself would sometimes turn the dollars into deposits in
bank accounts or use front companies to issue cashier’s checks.
But the Chinese clients often had their own options, such as
small businesses that handled cash without questions. Another method was
gambling at casinos, which readily turned cash into chips. Many clients bought
homes or paid US university tuition.
In testimony to a Canadian commission of inquiry in 2020,
Cassara, the former investigator at the US Treasury Department, described the
frequency of laundering in the US real estate sector.
“Almost 60% of purchases by international clients are made
in cash,” Cassara said, citing a report by the National Association of
Realtors. “Chinese buyers have been the top foreign buyers in the United States
both in units and dollar volume of residential housing for six years
straight.... In the United States, there is little if any customer due
diligence by real estate agents.”
The next step in Li’s system took place beyond the sight and
reach of US authorities. He directed his wealthy clients to transfer equivalent
sums from their Chinese bank accounts to accounts he controlled in China. Known
as “mirror transactions,” these transfers enabled Li to “sell” the same money
again — this time, as Chinese currency to the Latin American exporters.
There were variations on the system. Li sometimes washed
funds through companies owned by confederates in the United States and Latin
America who sold seafood and other goods to China.
Taking advantage of the $80 billion in trade between Mexico
and China, launderers also sent goods from China to Mexican front companies
connected to drug lords. Those companies would sell the products for pesos,
creating a legitimate paper trail for money initially earned from the sale of
drugs.
Li’s network used Chinese banks including the Industrial and
Commercial Bank of China and the Agricultural Bank of China, court documents
say. Those state institutions were among the banks that moved millions around
the world with little apparent scrutiny in this case and others, according to
court documents and interviews.
Comments
Post a Comment