Israeli-based binary options platform charged with $100m fraud in the U.S.
In a landmark enforcement action that tackles the very bedrock of Israel’s fraudulent binary options industry, the US Securities and Exchange Commission has filed fraud charges against SpotOption, a company at the heart of the multi-year scam that has defrauded victims worldwide out of billions, and against two of its top executives.
The SEC on Friday charged the Ramat Gan-based SpotOption,
which provided the platforms for a significant number of the hundreds of firms
that perpetrated the global fraud, as well as its two largest shareholders,
Malhaz Pinhas Patarkazishvili (also known as Pini Peter) and Ran Amiran, with
defrauding US investors out of over $100 million through “fraudulent and
unregistered online sales of risky securities known as binary options.” It
further alleges SpotOption used “deceptive and manipulative” tactics, including
rigging the trading platforms, to make certain that investors lost money.
The fraudulent binary options industry flourished for over a
decade, from 2007, until it was outlawed by the Knesset in 2017, as a direct
result of The Times of Israel’s investigative reporting, which began with a
March 2016 article entitled “The wolves of Tel Aviv: Israel’s vast, amoral binary
options scam exposed.” Many of the Israeli firms have since relocated overseas
and continued the scam.
SpotOption was secretively given hundreds of thousands of
dollars of government funding between 2014 and 2016 to expand its operations to
China, even as The Times of Israel was exposing the scam and regulators were
working to ban it.
SpotOption, which later changed its name to Spot Tech House
Ltd., was the largest binary options platform provider, used by hundreds of
websites, according to its own marketing material. SpotOption brokers employed
thousands of Israelis.
SpotOption and its shareholders defrauded American investors
from at least April 2012 through August 2017, the SEC alleges in its civil
enforcement action. People with knowledge of the company told The Times of
Israel that the total amount of money earned by SpotOption through allegedly
fraudulent binary options trading is in fact considerably higher than $100
million, and that the SEC has likely specified a figure it can efficiently
prove beyond a reasonable doubt.
Fraudulent binary options companies ostensibly offered
customers worldwide a potentially profitable short-term investment. But in
reality — through rigged trading platforms, refusal to pay out, and other ruses
— these companies fleeced the vast majority of customers out of most or all of
their money. The fraudulent salespeople routinely concealed where they were
located, misrepresented what they were selling, and used false identities.
Israel has not prosecuted any of the thousands of employees
of the binary options industry. The US Department of Justice has prosecuted
several key individuals, notably including Lee Elbaz, the CEO of Yukom
Communications Ltd. who was sentenced to 22 years in prison in 2019. Her
bosses, Yossi Herzog and Kobi Cohen, have both been indicted, and are still at
large.
According to the SEC’s complaint, SpotOption served as a
one-stop shop for “white label partners” who wished to start a binary options
website. These partners directly marketed binary options to investors around
the world without telling them that they were the counter-parties on all
investor trades. In other words, the websites, and SpotOption, made money when
investors lost money.
SpotOption provided these white-label partners with
everything they needed to start a brokerage, the SEC alleges. This included a
customized, “user-friendly,” website, a content management system or “CMS,”
software that allowed the brokers to create and edit content on their websites;
hosting and management of their websites; customer relationship management or
“CRM” software; third-party payment processing services; as well as training
and other services.
SpotOption marketed its platform to potential partners by
telling them that “the average investor lost 80% of their investment within
five months,” the SEC charge alleges.
The SEC further alleges that SpotOption employed “deceptive
and manipulative” tactics to cause investors to lose their money and
consequently earn money for SpotOption. These practices included “manipulating
the trading platform to increase the probability that trading would be
unprofitable” as well as offering investors a “bonus” that prevented investors
from withdrawing their funds.
According to the SEC, SpotOption targeted thousands of US
victims, including retirees.
“Many of those investors lost most of their money,
including, in some cases, hundreds of thousands of dollars meant for
retirement. SpotOption and its Partners, on the other hand, raked in millions
in profits,” the SEC complaint specifies.
“SpotOption’s trading platform allegedly supported a
worldwide binary options fraud,” said Jennifer S. Leete, associate director in
the SEC’s Enforcement Division, in an April 19 press release.
“This action shows that the SEC will work with its foreign
regulatory partners to pursue international actors who defraud US investors,”
the SEC’s complaint states.
From Georgia to Kazakhstan to Israel
SpotOption was founded by Malhaz Pinhas Patarkazishvili,
also known as Pini Peter, aged 45, an Israeli who was born in Georgia.
In 2005, Patarkazishvili was convicted of fraud, forgery,
and money laundering in Israel’s largest-ever bank theft, the Etti Alon Trade
Bank affair. Alon embezzled more than NIS 250 million — $70 million — and
served 14 years in jail. Patarkazishvili, working at a money changing store,
Moneynet Allenby, cashed some of the bank checks that Alon had embezzled.
Patarkazishvili was sentenced to a year in jail for the
offenses, unsuccessfully appealed to Israel’s Supreme Court, but ultimately had
his prison term commuted to six months’ community service by then-president
Shimon Peres.
After having his sentence commuted, Patarkazishvili became
the CEO of a high-tech company, EIM Telecom, that had won a lucrative contract
to develop a telecommunications network in Kazakhstan. That September,
Patarkazishvili was quoted telling Israel’s Globes business daily that the
deal, which he had personally signed with Kazakhstan’s communications minister,
was expected to bring in $10 million a year. “This is the first time that an
Israeli company is responsible for the overall development of an internal and
external communications network of a country in Central Asia,” he said.
He founded SpotOption in 2009, shortly after he bought a
Kazakh gambling machine company known as Vulkan KSI.
SpotOption eventually expanded to operate hundreds of
websites, according to its own marketing material. These included BigOption,
IvoryOption, Lbinary and many others.
One notable SpotOption brand belonged to a Russian binary
options company called Trustforex, in which Patarkazishvili’s father was until
recently a business partner with Igor Gorbenko and Boris Spektor.
Gorbenko and Spector are longtime business partners of
Yevgeny Prigozhin, who has been sanctioned by the US Treasury Department, for
operating a troll factory that interfered in the 2016 US presidential election,
as well as for “malign operations in Africa and Europe,” according to an April
15 press release.
Pini Peter is a major donor to the Chabad movement, and has
frequently mingled and met with prominent Israelis in the context of his
donations.
He has been photographed on numerous occasions with senior
Israeli politicians, including Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, Benny Gantz,
Gideon Sa’ar, Ron Huldai and others, in that context.
SpotOption sponsored a ceremony at Tel Aviv’s Great
Synagogue in 2015 at which new Torah scrolls were dedicated; the scrolls were
displayed in front of the SpotOption logo.
While Israel’s top financial regulator was working on the
legislation to outlaw all Israeli binary options firms and the Prime Minister’s
Office was urging a worldwide ban on the fraud-blighted industry, the Israeli
government secretively gave taxpayers’ money to SpotOption to help it expand
abroad, The Times of Israel revealed in 2017.
Government grants totaling some $270,000 were handed out
between 2014 and 2016, with the payments continuing even after Israeli
regulators banned binary options firms from targeting Israeli customers in
March 2016, a year before the Knesset banned binary options outright.
The SEC’s complaint was filed in federal district court in
Nevada. The investigation was conducted
by Deborah Maisel and Jason Anthony.
Comments
Post a Comment