How Mordechai Korf and Uriel Laber Helped A Ukrainian Tycoon Launder Millions
In the early 1990s, Mordechai Korf and Uriel Laber traveled to Ukraine as Jewish humanitarian volunteers as the country gained its independence and ended Soviet restrictions on religion.
Korf was still a teenager just out of a rabbinical institute
when he arrived in 1991. His friend Laber, whom he met at a religious school in
Detroit, came a few years later.
When they returned to the United States more than a decade
later, they were -- on paper at least -- running a commercial empire from Miami
whose assets ranged from steel and alloy plants to industrial tires and real
estate that cost more than $1 billion to cobble together.
Korf and Laber purchased lavish homes in Miami Beach. Each
were donating millions of dollars to Jewish charities, earning themselves
reputations as generous philanthropists.
Now the story of two young humanitarian workers with little
to no business experience striking it rich during Ukraine's turbulent -- and
sometimes violent -- transition to a market economy is under question.
They are accused by the U.S. Justice Department of helping
two Ukrainian tycoons over the course of a decade launder hundreds of millions
of dollars in misappropriated funds from a Kyiv-based bank and then invest the
ill-gotten wealth in U.S. assets, profiting handsomely in the process.
One of the tycoons is one of Ukraine's wealthiest and most
influential citizens, a businessman who helped propel a former stand-up
comedian and TV actor into Ukraine's presidency in 2019.
That man, Ihor Kolomoyskiy, and his associate, Hennadiy
Boholyubov, have denied the accusations, saying the money used to purchase the
U.S. assets that Korf and Laber now run came from the sale of their Ukrainian
steel business to a Russian competitor for $2 billion.
Neither the tycoons nor the Miami businessmen have been
criminally charged; the Justice Department lawsuit announced on August 6 is a
civil action aimed at seizing assets deemed to have been ill-gotten. The
department says, however, that its investigation is continuing.
Two days prior to the Justice Department's announcement, FBI
agents raided the Miami penthouse office of Korf and Laber from which they run
the companies beneficially owned by Kolomoyskiy and Boholyubov.
Korf and Laber, through their attorney Marc Kasowitz, denied
the U.S. government's allegations, asserting they were "part of an
orchestrated political attack" against Kolomoyskiy and Boholyubov by
shareholders of PrivatBank.
Ukraine Heritage, Dnipro Beginnings
Over the years, Korf and Laber have rarely, if ever,
referred to Kolomoyskiy and Boholyubov in press releases issued by various
companies sharing the name Optima. But their ties go back at least 20 years and
span a wide range of industries, from telecommunications and metals to oil and
gas.
The rise of Korf and Laber as wealthy businessmen began in
Kolomoyskiy's hometown of Dnipro (then still known as Dnipropetrovsk),
Ukraine's fourth-largest city and a major industrial hub with about 1 million
residents.
They did not end up there randomly.
Dnipro is also the former hometown of a rabbi whom many in
the Orthodox Jewish movement known as Chabad-Lubavitch consider to be a
religious messiah. Korf and Laber both belong to the movement.
The rabbi, Menachem Mendel Schneerson, made reviving Judaism
in Dnipro a priority as the Soviet Union eased religious restrictions.
Schneerson's father was Dnipro's chief rabbi for decades until he was arrested
by the Soviet government in 1939.
Schneerson had also officiated at the marriage of Korf's
parents in New York and sent Korf's father to run a Chabad-Lubavitch community
in Miami.
In 1990, Schneerson sent 25-year-old Rabbi Shmuel Kaminezki
to Dnipro to help rebuild the Jewish community. A year later, Korf, whose
father fled from Soviet Ukraine decades earlier, arrived in Dnipro. Laber came
in 1994.
At the time, the country was struggling with the wrenching
shift to a capitalist economy. Shortages of consumer goods were common and
savvy entrepreneurs were making millions of dollars importing products from
abroad.
Korf, whose formal education appears to have ended at the
religious school he attended in New York, was one of them. By 1995, Korf and
Laber set up a Florida-registered company called Optima International of Miami.
In an interview in 2017, he recalled his early days in
Ukraine, saying that he began trading products such as light bulbs and hammers
"back and forth."
On a larger scale, Korf and Laber began buying up shares of
oil and natural gas companies as part of a privatization process that, like
Russia, Ukraine undertook in the 1990s. For savvy investors, it became a way to
take control of major companies. The industrial center of Dnipro had some of
the country's most attractive assets.
A media strategist who published a glowing post about the
two men in 2019 alluded to a famous line from a U.S. comedy film, The Blues
Brothers, to describe their supposed remarkable success. "In the history
of great partnerships, few people can attribute their origins to having been on
a Mission from God," the article said. "Mordechai Korf and Uriel
Laber fit that bill."
According to the post, published on the financial blog
Seeking Alpha, Korf and Laber set up tables near factories to buy shares from workers
-- a common practice in those days -- and sell them a year or two later
"for a tidy profit."
RFE/RL sent questions to Korf and Laber regarding their
participation in the privatization process, including where the men got the
money to buy shares in the first place. They declined to answer.
When contacted by RFE/RL regarding his post, the author of
the article said he did not work for Korf and Laber and declined to answer any
further questions.
Exactly when and how Korf and Laber began working with Kolomoyskiy
and Boholyubov, who consolidated stakes in Ukrainian energy companies in the
1990s, is unclear.
The Justice Department said the Miami businessmen sold a
stake in Optima to Kolomoyskiy and Boholyubov, but did not give details on the
timing, size, or cost of the transaction. Korf and Laber declined to say when
they sold the stake.
By 2000, Korf and Laber were doing business with the tycoons
on various investments, including privatizations and acquisitions, according to
the Seeking Alpha article. Kolomoyskiy and Boholyubov eventually named Laber to
the board of Ukrnafta, Ukraine's largest oil producer.
In a 2002 book about Jewish diaspora communities, Laber was
quoted as saying that he was introduced to his "Russian partners" --
an apparent reference to Kolomoyskiy and Boholyubov, as many people in eastern
Ukraine speak Russian as their first language -- by Kaminezki, the rabbi who
arrived in Dnipro in 1990.
"I didn't know who was honest and who wasn't, who we
could work with, all the problems you run into in this part of the world.
Without [Kaminezki] saying that 'this is an honest person' we wouldn't have
known," Laber was quoted as saying. "Anyone can introduce you to
another person; the point here is the reliability. He knows what's up,
basically."
Kaminezki's characterization of Kolomoyskiy -- as recounted
by Laber -- clashes with those who view the tycoon as among the country's worst
corporate raiders.
Kaminezki's connections went beyond the local Jewish
community to the city's most influential people. In 2008, he was recognized by
a Ukrainian publication as one of the 15 most "powerful foreigners"
in the country.
Telecom Battle
There is little public information about the various
investments the Miami businessmen made with the tycoons in Ukraine.
One investment in which Korf was involved in the early 2000s
related to a Ukrainian telecommunications venture that he and Kolomoyskiy
fought to take control of, according to several Kyiv Post articles.
As part of the fight for the operator, called Ukrainian
Radio Systems, the two reportedly ordered that a group of Koreans who were
helping manage the operation be physically removed from a company building.
In 2010, Korf was sued in Florida by two Ukrainian investors
who accused him of stealing a 10 percent stake in the operator and parking it
in an offshore shell company. That stake was later sold to a bigger Russian
telecom operator for $23 million.
The lawsuit ultimately went nowhere: one of the investors
later dropped out, while the other settled with Korf, according to court
records.
U.S. Steel
Whatever success the Miami businessmen and the tycoons
achieved together in Ukraine, it was not matched in the United States, where
they went through bankruptcies, shutdowns, and foreclosures.
According to corporate records, Korf and Laber ran four
sizable businesses, including a specialty steel firm, a ferroalloy holding, a
commercial real-estate business, and an industrial tire company.
Their steel company, Optima Specialty Steel, owned seven
plants in five states. It filed for bankruptcy in 2016, resulting in the loss
of roughly $200 million that Korf and his partners had invested in the
business.
Ohio-based Warren Steel permanently shut down in 2016.
Michigan-based Steel Rolling was idle for the majority of the time the men
owned it before they sold it in 2015, according to media reports.
Another company, Georgian-American Alloys, has faced
repeated work stoppages at its two U.S. plants over several years. Its Kentucky
division is temporarily closed while its West Virginia business has only one of
three lines operating, and the West Virginia operation has lost money most of
its operating life, its chief financial officer said in 2013.
The men also invested in commercial real estate in various
U.S. cities through a company called Optima Ventures.
They paid $16 million for an empty Illinois-based commercial
campus but never found a tenant to occupy it. They sold it eight years later
for $7 million less after having paid several million in property taxes and
utilities.
However, Optima's actual loss was likely much greater due to
taxes and maintenance costs that it paid over those eight years, according to
Charles Eldredge, director of an economic development corporation in the region
where the building is located. "It became quite clear from the beginning
that they were speculators who thought they bought property at an inexpensive
price and then would be able to resell it at a profit," Eldredge told
RFE/RL. "And that did not work out for them."
Another office building in Dallas, Texas, has been without a
tenant since 2016, while a building in Louisville, Kentucky, saw a massive fall
in occupancy following a bank merger. Optima Ventures paid about $125 million
for the two buildings, according to court documents; the Justice Department,
which is seeking to seize the two properties, now estimates they are worth just
$70 million.
The FBI, which is an arm of the Justice Department, said
following their August 4 raid that their investigation is continuing.
For his part, Kolomoyskiy has rejected the U.S. accusations
of embezzlement, fraud, and money laundering, saying the funds used to purchase
the U.S. assets came from the sale of his stake in Ukrainian metals assets to a
Russian giant called Evraz. He says he and his partners received $2 billion
from the sale.
Kolomoyskiy fled Ukraine in 2017 amid concerns over
prosecution and a falling out with then-President Petro Poroshenko. He returned
to the country a month after Volodymyr Zelenskiy defeated Poroshenko in April
2019 to win the presidency.
He is now locked in a bitter battle for control of
PrivatBank, which was nationalized in December 2016.
A civil lawsuit filed in Delaware court in the United States
claims Kolomoyskiy and his partners laundered $780 million into the U.S.
financial system through a series of bogus loans issued to companies they
control.
PrivatBank has dubbed the alleged fraud the Optima Schemes
because the U.S. assets were largely controlled by companies with the name
Optima.
Kolomoyskiy has denied the allegations.
Comments
Post a Comment